DM: Alright, so now you're on your way to Canterlot. Probably on a royal flying chariot for expediency. That gives us an opportunity to talk about this round of level-ups! There's a power and a couple of feats, but the most important detail is your Paragon Path – the concept that defines your character's growth over the next ten levels. So let's focus on that.
Twilight Sparkle: I'll get mine out of the way. I went with Academy Master, obviously. Bookworm and all that… But it does mean a little bit of extra accuracy and damage for my arcane attacks, so… don't count out the boring-but-functional options!
DM: It's very fitting.
Pinkie Pie: Me next! I went with… Karmic Shaper!
DM: No surprise in retrospect. Man, that flavor change to Virtue of Prescience is really paying dividends, huh?
Pinkie Pie: Absolutely! I thought just being a Bard would be fun enough when we started, but I am ALL IN on this new angle of reality-bending luck manipulation!
DM: I fear what you'll be like at level 30.
Applejack: I went with, ehh… Pathfinder. It works well with mah two-weapon build. Flavor-wise… Ah dunno, Ah kinda wanna be the gal that's dependable in a fight, who can get the party where it needs to go. Somethin' like that.
Twilight Sparkle: Boring-but-functional Paragon Paths, unite!
Applejack: …Sure, why not.
Rainbow Dash: My turn! BLOODFURY SAVAGE!!
DM: …A bit of context. That's a Half-Orc racial PP, but–
Rainbow Dash: I hated pretty much all of my basic options. In Barbarian AND Monk.
DM: Since I didn't come up with racial Paths for ponies, I gave you all some wiggle room.
Applejack: So why Bloodfury Savage?
Rainbow Dash: Because rainbow-colored ball of death. Duh.
DM: Way to fit in with the setting, as always.
Rarity: For me, it was a no-brainer: Guildmaster Thief. Mechanically, it's interesting but situational – its main gimmick is being able to use allies' action points and vice versa. But the flavor… well. I'm not sure yet if I intend to stay with the Thieves' Guild when all is said and done. But no one can deny that we have transcended Elusive's shadow. In time, Rarity WILL be a Guildmaster-level thief, regardless of her eventual affiliation. Of that, have no doubt.
DM: I appreciate the open-ended approach. Now, I think that just leaves Fluttershy. What did you pick for your Paragon Path?
Fluttershy: I um… I went with something called… Keeper of the Hidden Flame.
DM: What's that?
Fluttershy: The idea is that, um, there's a spark of vigor in every creature… especially in the predators of the wild. Reading the description reminded me of that time I stood up to a dragon. It made me think… Fluttershy might have a hidden flame inside her. So I sort of want to… see where that goes.
DM: I just want to be clear, this level-up wasn't a character-development competition or anything. …But if it was, you won.
Rainbow Dash: Yep.
Rarity: I concede.